It is still the case that many people don’t know that there is no such thing as “common law” marriage. This very often means that, on separation, the financially weaker party has little or no protection in law when a relationship ends, irrespective of how long the parties have been together.
Unlike on divorce, there is no mechanism in law for an ex-partner to be granted financial relief such as a property to live in, a lump sum, maintenance for themselves or to have a share of the other’s pension.
If one partner has worked outside the home during the relationship and built up a career, no credit is given on separation to a partner who may have stayed at home to look after children.
The law could be set to change following the Government’s recent consultation on reforming the law for cohabitants on separation in the document: “A Fairer End to Relationships.”
A major statutory framework has been proposed to grant new legal rights to qualifying cohabitees. Under the proposals, couples who have lived together for three years (or less if they have a child) would qualify for automatic protections upon separation or death.
While family law bodies like Resolution have long campaigned for this, the draft legislation is sparking fierce debate in the legal community. Let’s look at both sides of the coin.
The Case For Reform: Protecting the Vulnerable
From a solicitor’s point of view, the arguments in favour of updating our legal system are deeply compelling:
- Busting the Myth and Preventing Financial Ruin: Millions of people wrongly believe they are legally protected. When a relationship ends, the financially weaker partner, often a mother who sacrificed her career to raise children, can walk away with absolutely nothing. The new law would provide a statutory framework to meet basic financial needs.
- Replacing an Outdated, Costly Legal Patchwork: Currently, unmarried couples must fight property disputes using complex trust law (specifically, the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996). These cases are notoriously unpredictable, rigid, and expensive. A streamlined family court process would reduce legal costs and emotional stress.
- Safety Net on Death: Under current rules, if a partner dies without a will, the survivor inherits nothing automatically. The proposal introduces vital automatic inheritance rights under intestacy rules, preventing grieving partners from being forced out of their homes.
- Reflecting Modern Family Realities: Cohabitation is the fastest-growing family type in the UK. The law must adapt to how people actually live today rather than penalising those who choose not to marry.
The Case Against Reform: Autonomy and Ambiguity
Despite the obvious benefits, critics raise valid concerns about the unintended consequences of the proposed framework:
- Infringing on the Freedom to Choose: Many couples deliberately choose not to marry precisely because they want to keep their finances separate. Imposing an automatic “opt-out” system means couples could accidentally find themselves bound by legal financial obligations simply by living together for more than three years.
- The Burden of Opting Out: While couples can choose to opt out of the new rules, this requires executing a formal cohabitation agreement. Critics argue that vulnerable partners may face emotional pressure or coercion from the wealthier partner to sign an opt-out clause, undermining the law’s protective intent.
- Legal Uncertainty and Litigation: Defining exactly when cohabitation began is notoriously difficult. Did the clock start when someone left a toothbrush, or when both names went on the electoral roll? Solicitors foresee a wave of costly litigation just trying to prove whether a couple met the qualifying timeline.
- Diluting the Status of Marriage: Some argue that by narrowing the gap between cohabitation and marriage, the state reduces the unique social and legal incentive to marry or enter a civil partnership.
The Solicitor’s Perspective
The proposed shift represents the most significant shake-up to English family law in a generation. While it introduces necessary protections for dependent partners and children, it also means couples must become far more proactive about their relationship status.
If the law passes, “living together” will no longer be a legally neutral act. Unmarried couples will need to seek early legal advice to understand whether they should draft a formal cohabitation agreement to protect their independent assets.
If you are currently cohabiting or planning to move in with a partner, we can provide tailored advice to you on:
- How a cohabitation agreement works under current and proposed laws
- What steps you can take right now to protect your property?
- How to draft a Will to secure your partner’s future?
Need advice about your legal rights as a cohabiting couple? Speak to our Family team on 0114 218 4000 or email Family.ClientServices@tayloremmet.co.uk